Top 10 Albums of the Aughties

1) Radiohead: Kid A (2000)
After 1995′s bombastic The Bends and 1997′s soaring OK Computer, Radiohead had established themselves as the saviors of rock in an era dominated by the Backstreet Boys and Puff Daddy. Then they came up with Kid A, an icy and cerebral record with exactly one rock song steeped in the melancholy atmopherics of Scott Walker and the jittery electronics of the Warp Records catalog. Though it was released to mixed reviews and divided audiences nine years ago, Kid A is now almost universally regarded as the greatest album of its time, a bold and brilliant reinvention of the rock record whose current influence is rivaled only by The Beatles.

2) The Strokes: Is This It (2001)
The real saviors of rock came a year later from the heart of New York City. Is This It is an unusual record because of its restraint: each instrument is played impeccably and neatly inhabits its own little space, seemingly unaware of what the others are doing. They’re unified by the growling voice of Julian Casablancas, the only uncontrolled element in an otherwise immaculate package, which over the course of each song incites all of the perfect little instruments to rock out, albeit in a very demure fashion. Is This It is short, concise and perfect, a feat the band has struggled to replicate with their subsequent filler-heavy records. And let us not forget that The Strokes singlehandedly spawned an NYC rock renaissance, thrusting some of the decade’s best bands — including Yeah Yeah Yeahs, TV On The Radio and Interpol — into the spotlight.

3) OutKast: Stankonia (2000)
Its manic psychedelic centerpiece “B.O.B.” is the the decade’s best song, but Stankonia as a whole is also one of the greatest hip hop albums ever recorded, a record as bright and kinetic as its superb predecessor Aquemini was moody and mysterious. Recorded in the duo’s prime, every track is a dazzling burst of creative energy, from the heartfelt funk of “Ms. Jackson” to the scatterbrained experimentation of “?” to the socially conscious bossa nova of “Humble Mumble”. Though in retrospect it’s bittersweet that Stankonia marks the last time that Big Boi and Andre 3000 found themselves on the same page, it’s a vibrant swan song for one of the most fruitful musical partnerships ever (Lennon/McCartney, Hall/Oates, Boi/3000).

4) LCD Soundsystem: Sound of Silver (2007)
Sound of Silver isn’t the purest distillation of dance-punk, the decade’s most exciting musical movement that was largely created by LCD’s frontman James Murphy (that honor would go to Disc 2 of their debut self-titled album). It’s more of a variation on the genre which adds depth and soulfulness to a style not known for having much on its mind. Composed largely of epics (more than half of its songs run past the six minute mark), Sound of Silver is a strange and magnificent dance record about loss and aging.

5) Arcade Fire: Neon Bible (2007)
Arcade Fire’s glorious debut Funeral made a much bigger splash critically than its slicker second record Neon Bible, but in many ways it feels like a scattershot demo compared to the absolute triumph that followed it. Neon Bible was the band’s first record after achieving critical darling status and the heightened anticipation that goes along with it, and they rise to the challenge with boundless energy and intensity, along with a set of timeless songs. More than any other band working today, Arcade Fire is searching for meaning in a frivolous world…

6) Justin Timberlake: FutureSex/LoveSounds (2006)
…which is not to say that frivolousness can’t be a lot of fun. Justin Timberlake is the George Clooney of pop music, a handsome dude who has decided to use his good looks and considerable talent for projects he cares about. Unlike his fellow pop brethren who crank out a subpar release every November to sell as stocking stuffers, Timberlake waited four years between his excellent solo debut Justified and (the admittedly ridiculously titled) FutureSex/LoveSounds. The result is the greatest pop record of the decade, a modern day Thriller that feels alive and spontaneous where most pop seems stilted and focus-grouped. Let’s hope the four year gap between FS/LS and his next record is just as productive.

7) Madvillain: Madvillainy (2004)
DOOM and Madlib are eccentric, reclusive geniuses with a somewhat spotty track record given how shockingly prolific they are. So when news of their collaborative project Madvillain leaked, no one knew what to expect; would we have a legendary hip hop summit of epic proportions or a thrown together one-off from some eggheads with other things on their minds? Thankfully, Madvillainy emerged an instant classic bursting at the seams with ideas: most tracks clock in at a minute or two because because these guys are so inspired that they’ve got to get to the next thing.

8) M.I.A.: Kala (2007)
Boy, did I love M.I.A.’s debut Arular. I love hip hip, Bhangra, Afrobeat, dancehall… basically everything M.I.A.’s into, and she stirred them together into a delicious stew of global harmony and put a Baltimore club beat behind it. Then Kala came out and truly blew my mind. It’s a darker, harder, more expansive and more complicated record that takes risks and succeeds wildly. Who else would think of singing “Where Is My Mind?” over a track that sounds like a mechanical apocalypse, or sampling a long-forgotten song from a 1982 Bollywood film called Disco Dancer, or mixing “Rumpshaker” with the Clash’s “Straight To Hell”?

9) Midlake: Trials of Van Occupanther (2006)
The most beautiful record of the decade came from an unlikely source: a five-piece from Denton, TX, drawing inspiration from lush 70′s rock like Fleetwood Mac and America. But gorgeous strummy tracks like “Bandits” and “It Covers The Hillsides” prove how unique and vital this band is. It’s such a shame that Van Occupanther‘s two biggest standouts didn’t become huge hits; the unforgettable “Young Bride” layers ornate strings over relentless percussion, and “Roscoe” is the type of soulful rock Kings of Leon would kill to write.

10) Animal Collective: Merriweather Post Pavilion (2009)
It seems fitting that a decade that kicked off with Kid A‘s glacial electronic soundscapes comes to a close with Animal Collective’s warm, inviting, hopeful ones. There’s not much more that I can write about Animal Collective or Merriweather Post Pavilion that I haven’t said before, except that this record absolutely belongs in this esteemed company even though we haven’t been listening to it as long as the others. In fact, everyone will probably think it deserves a much higher position 10 years from now.

  • http://www.scott-howard.com/ Scott Howard

    This is a bit of a cheat, but 10 more (in alphabetical order) that almost made the cut: Annie: Anniemal, Franz Ferdinand: s/t, Ghostface: Fish Scale, Goldfrapp: Black Cherry, Jay-Z: The Blueprint, Kanye West: Late Registration, PJ Harvey: Stories from the City Stories from the Sea, Ted Leo: Hearts of Oak, TV on the Radio: Return To Cookie Mountain, Yeah Yeah Yeahs: Fever To Tell.

    This was a damn fine decade of music.

  • http://www.scott-howard.com Scott Howard

    This is a bit of a cheat, but 10 more (in alphabetical order) that almost made the cut: Annie: Anniemal, Franz Ferdinand: s/t, Ghostface: Fish Scale, Goldfrapp: Black Cherry, Jay-Z: The Blueprint, Kanye West: Late Registration, PJ Harvey: Stories from the City Stories from the Sea, Ted Leo: Hearts of Oak, TV on the Radio: Return To Cookie Mountain, Yeah Yeah Yeahs: Fever To Tell.

    This was a damn fine decade of music.

  • Pingback: Twitted by mrhoward

  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments

  • Paul Starr

    Howard, Howard, Howard. Shiina Ringo’s KZK album still isn’t on that list, and I KNOW I lent you that shit. What is your problem?

    Also Radiohead is the most deeply, gigantically overrated band of the decade. They’re the Pink Floyd of the Aughties. That’s right, I said it.

  • Paul Starr

    Howard, Howard, Howard. Shiina Ringo’s KZK album still isn’t on that list, and I KNOW I lent you that shit. What is your problem?

    Also Radiohead is the most deeply, gigantically overrated band of the decade. They’re the Pink Floyd of the Aughties. That’s right, I said it.

  • Paul Starr

    I guess what I mean to say is why don’t your opinions agree perfectly with me? It’s like you’re a different person, or something.

    Seriously, though, I do not understand what everybody hears when they listen to Radiohead. I hear a bunch of noise and mumbly lyrics. Maybe someday they’ll click for me, but that day has not yet come.

  • Paul Starr

    I guess what I mean to say is why don’t your opinions agree perfectly with me? It’s like you’re a different person, or something.

    Seriously, though, I do not understand what everybody hears when they listen to Radiohead. I hear a bunch of noise and mumbly lyrics. Maybe someday they’ll click for me, but that day has not yet come.

  • http://sodapopjournal.com Robert Cortez

    No worries, Paul. I’m also in the Radiohead I Don’t Get It Club.

    I’m pleased to see some of the other names here (Madvillain, holla!), although I really, REALLY think Kanye’s The College Dropout belongs in here too. I think that was a big turning point for hip hop in terms of lyrical content, attitude and even production. And really, six years later, who’s still more polarizing than Kanye?

  • http://levelorange.com Robert Cortez

    No worries, Paul. I’m also in the Radiohead I Don’t Get It Club.

    I’m pleased to see some of the other names here (Madvillain, holla!), although I really, REALLY think Kanye’s The College Dropout belongs in here too. I think that was a big turning point for hip hop in terms of lyrical content, attitude and even production. And really, six years later, who’s still more polarizing than Kanye?

  • http://www.scott-howard.com/ Scott Howard

    You and Robert both dissin’ on my Radiohead love! I suggested a playlist to him in the comments here, where HE dissed me: http://tinyurl.com/yfkf5xg

    Also, jeez dude, Pink Floyd was bloated and excessive, sure, but they had a pretty great 15 year run.

  • http://www.scott-howard.com Scott Howard

    You and Robert both dissin’ on my Radiohead love! I suggested a playlist to him in the comments here, where HE dissed me: http://tinyurl.com/yfkf5xg

    Also, jeez dude, Pink Floyd was bloated and excessive, sure, but they had a pretty great 15 year run.

  • http://www.scott-howard.com/ Scott Howard

    OMG ROBERT YOU’RE BACK TO DISS ME AGAIN???

    You know I love Kanye (#2 in my best artists of the decade list, don’t forget), and I REEEEALLY wanted to get Late Registration on this list, but there’s just too much goodness. I always preferred LR to Dropout too, which I thought was half killer half filler (yes, I’m a 70′s DJ).

  • http://www.scott-howard.com Scott Howard

    OMG ROBERT YOU’RE BACK TO DISS ME AGAIN???

    You know I love Kanye (#2 in my best artists of the decade list, don’t forget), and I REEEEALLY wanted to get Late Registration on this list, but there’s just too much goodness. I always preferred LR to Dropout too, which I thought was half killer half filler (yes, I’m a 70′s DJ).

  • http://sodapopjournal.com Robert Cortez

    Look at me! I’m back to cold diss you again, AGAIN. (When did we jump back to the ’90s?)

    Regarding Radiohead, I may never get the music entirely but didn’t say they don’t belong on the list. I know a lot of people are into them. That’s A-OK.

    As far as Late Registration, I also like it better than The College Dropout but that’s the album that got the Kanye ball rolling. Plus, you just trippin’. :D

  • http://levelorange.com Robert Cortez

    Look at me! I’m back to cold diss you again, AGAIN. (When did we jump back to the ’90s?)

    Regarding Radiohead, I may never get the music entirely but didn’t say they don’t belong on the list. I know a lot of people are into them. That’s A-OK.

    As far as Late Registration, I also like it better than The College Dropout but that’s the album that got the Kanye ball rolling. Plus, you just trippin’. :D

  • http://www.scott-howard.com/ Scott Howard

    You cold busted me like Oran Juice Jones!

    Ladies and gentlemen, let the record ALSO state that Robert DOESN’T LIKE GHOSTFACE! How can you trust such a fellow?!

  • http://www.scott-howard.com Scott Howard

    You cold busted me like Oran Juice Jones!

    Ladies and gentlemen, let the record ALSO state that Robert DOESN’T LIKE GHOSTFACE! How can you trust such a fellow?!

  • http://twitter.com/mynameis_shoe shoe

    I love that this list has some nice surprises, but I really think it’s missing Daft Punk’s “Discovery” and Wilco’s “Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.” I’d probably remove Midlake (only because it doesn’t belong this high in a decade ranking) and The Strokes; yeah, I remember how huge that record was, but in terms of impact, it really hasn’t made much.
    And to the “I don’t get Radiohead” guys: I pity you. Radiohead is where my love of music began, and I can basically tell you my life story according to their discography. Most important band of the decade? Sure, but they’re the most important band to me. That, ultimately, counts the most.

  • http://twitter.com/mynameis_shoe shoe

    I love that this list has some nice surprises, but I really think it’s missing Daft Punk’s “Discovery” and Wilco’s “Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.” I’d probably remove Midlake (only because it doesn’t belong this high in a decade ranking) and The Strokes; yeah, I remember how huge that record was, but in terms of impact, it really hasn’t made much.
    And to the “I don’t get Radiohead” guys: I pity you. Radiohead is where my love of music began, and I can basically tell you my life story according to their discography. Most important band of the decade? Sure, but they’re the most important band to me. That, ultimately, counts the most.

  • http://www.scott-howard.com/ Scott Howard

    Well said, Shoe! I love making lists, but they’re pointless if they don’t reflect the person who writes them. Otherwise, just look at a Metacritic score and make your judgments that way.

    Daft Punk’s one of my favorites, but I always lost interest in Discovery around the halfway mark. “One More Time” is definitely in the top 5 singles of the decade, though. I think I missed the window for Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, which I didn’t hear until 2006/7, and I liked it well enough but never really fell in love with it.

    The Strokes definitely never recorded another full album as good as Is This It (though you could probably put together a mix from their next three that would get pretty close), but I think they kickstarted rock in general again after a 5 or 6 year lull following the death of grunge. Is This It really is kind of a perfect record to me: tight, fresh, superbly sequenced, and full of simple but unforgettable hooks. And Midlake is a bit of a sentimental choice, but I listened that record almost every day for about a year and a half, so it was a major part of the decade for me musically.

  • http://www.scott-howard.com Scott Howard

    Well said, Shoe! I love making lists, but they’re pointless if they don’t reflect the person who writes them. Otherwise, just look at a Metacritic score and make your judgments that way.

    Daft Punk’s one of my favorites, but I always lost interest in Discovery around the halfway mark. “One More Time” is definitely in the top 5 singles of the decade, though. I think I missed the window for Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, which I didn’t hear until 2006/7, and I liked it well enough but never really fell in love with it.

    The Strokes definitely never recorded another full album as good as Is This It (though you could probably put together a mix from their next three that would get pretty close), but I think they kickstarted rock in general again after a 5 or 6 year lull following the death of grunge. Is This It really is kind of a perfect record to me: tight, fresh, superbly sequenced, and full of simple but unforgettable hooks. And Midlake is a bit of a sentimental choice, but I listened that record almost every day for about a year and a half, so it was a major part of the decade for me musically.

  • Dr. Neptune

    This list is most refreshing! Kid A is without question the definitive album to what is now being called “the decade from hell” and I like your ballsy move of including Neon Bible instead of Funeral. But really, props for the Madvillain love as that was one of my personal top five of the decade.

    I roughly decided my personal five may possible be (not sure about order):
    ~ Radiohead – In Rainbows (mainly because it was so great to hear them grow from being so icy and alienated on Kid A to warm and groove oriented but in a very unique, Radiohead-y kind of way)
    ~ Sigur Ros – Agaetis Byrjun (definitely a member of this cult, will be endlessly imitated but never duplicated)
    ~ Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (I was pretty resistant to this at first but have come to be a huge fan)
    ~ Madvillain – Madvillainy (I always like the indie hip hop “worlds colliding albums best and just as Dr. Octagon’s Kool Keith meets Automator and Q Bert was my fave last decade, Madlib’s teaming with MF Doom takes the cake)
    ~ Yo La Tengo – And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out (for the decade in which indie stuff broke through in full force, YLT laid out their own blueprint for these youngsters to follow 15 years from now to act their age and still make amazing, haunting records)

  • Dr. Neptune

    This list is most refreshing! Kid A is without question the definitive album to what is now being called “the decade from hell” and I like your ballsy move of including Neon Bible instead of Funeral. But really, props for the Madvillain love as that was one of my personal top five of the decade.

    I roughly decided my personal five may possible be (not sure about order):
    ~ Radiohead – In Rainbows (mainly because it was so great to hear them grow from being so icy and alienated on Kid A to warm and groove oriented but in a very unique, Radiohead-y kind of way)
    ~ Sigur Ros – Agaetis Byrjun (definitely a member of this cult, will be endlessly imitated but never duplicated)
    ~ Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (I was pretty resistant to this at first but have come to be a huge fan)
    ~ Madvillain – Madvillainy (I always like the indie hip hop “worlds colliding albums best and just as Dr. Octagon’s Kool Keith meets Automator and Q Bert was my fave last decade, Madlib’s teaming with MF Doom takes the cake)
    ~ Yo La Tengo – And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out (for the decade in which indie stuff broke through in full force, YLT laid out their own blueprint for these youngsters to follow 15 years from now to act their age and still make amazing, haunting records)

  • Paul Starr

    And to the “I don’t get Radiohead” guys: I pity you.

    You pity me? Well, pal, you’ve never heard Shiina Ringo, you’ve never heard Dominic Frontiere’s On Any Sunday soundtrack, you’ve never heard globe’s Relation album, and you’ve never seen The Back Horn live, so I guess I pity you, too! Here we are, pitying each other for having different musical experiences. Good times!

    My top five albums of the decade, off the top of my head in no order: Shiina Ringo’s KZK, The Go! Team’s Proof of Youth, Gogol Bordello’s Super Taranta, Bishop Allen’s The Broken String, and Sufjan Stevens’ Illinoise.

  • Paul Starr

    And to the “I don’t get Radiohead” guys: I pity you.

    You pity me? Well, pal, you’ve never heard Shiina Ringo, you’ve never heard Dominic Frontiere’s On Any Sunday soundtrack, you’ve never heard globe’s Relation album, and you’ve never seen The Back Horn live, so I guess I pity you, too! Here we are, pitying each other for having different musical experiences. Good times!

    My top five albums of the decade, off the top of my head in no order: Shiina Ringo’s KZK, The Go! Team’s Proof of Youth, Gogol Bordello’s Super Taranta, Bishop Allen’s The Broken String, and Sufjan Stevens’ Illinoise.

  • Ellen Wernecke

    I loved Is This It. I haven’t done my whole top 10 but that would have a great shot at making it if I did. Justin Timberlake would probably not but I still love you for daring to put him and Arcade Fire on the same list. Is that a collab I smell??

    My top 5 is disproportionately weighted towards 2001 anyway:

    Rufus Wainwright, Poses
    Interpol, Turn On The Bright Lights
    Jay-Z, The Blueprint
    Wilco, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
    The Hold Steady, Separation Sunday

  • Ellen Wernecke

    I loved Is This It. I haven’t done my whole top 10 but that would have a great shot at making it if I did. Justin Timberlake would probably not but I still love you for daring to put him and Arcade Fire on the same list. Is that a collab I smell??

    My top 5 is disproportionately weighted towards 2001 anyway:

    Rufus Wainwright, Poses
    Interpol, Turn On The Bright Lights
    Jay-Z, The Blueprint
    Wilco, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
    The Hold Steady, Separation Sunday

  • http://sodapopjournal.com Robert Cortez

    I went back and listened to Is This It and I think you pretty much nailed my thoughts on it, Scott. I always wondered how The Strokes never really pulled it off again, but maybe that one album was all it took to spark the movement it did so that others could follow suit.

    Oh and so i might not really get Radiohead but for what it’s worth, I can say that the Thom Yorke song “Hearing Damage” was definitely one of the highlights of Twilight: New Moon. That I am sure of. :)

    And I dig all of Futuresex/Lovesounds but for my money, “My Love” is such a perfect mix of styles and genres that it just about redefines the contemporary R&B; ballad. Good stuff!

  • http://levelorange.com Robert Cortez

    I went back and listened to Is This It and I think you pretty much nailed my thoughts on it, Scott. I always wondered how The Strokes never really pulled it off again, but maybe that one album was all it took to spark the movement it did so that others could follow suit.

    Oh and so i might not really get Radiohead but for what it’s worth, I can say that the Thom Yorke song “Hearing Damage” was definitely one of the highlights of Twilight: New Moon. That I am sure of. :)

    And I dig all of Futuresex/Lovesounds but for my money, “My Love” is such a perfect mix of styles and genres that it just about redefines the contemporary R&B ballad. Good stuff!