
Game of Thrones: “Baelor”, “Fire and Blood”
Robert: All’s well that ends well—except in Westeros, where apparently nothing ever ends well. It’s some kind of twisted fate that Tyrion should be thrown into the front lines of battle and live to see another day while Ned, thinking his life had been mercifully spared, ends up paying the ultimate price. Unfortunately, I discovered that shocking development by complete accident (in trying to remember all the characters’ names early on, I wandered over to Wikipedia and was almost immediately spoiled on Ned’s misfortune) but like the story of an ill-fated Apollo mission or a doomed White Star Line ocean liner, it’s always interesting to see how things play out even when you know the end result. Knowing that Ned stuck to his guns and that Sansa and Arya—now on opposite sides of the same coin, it seems—are going to be all that’s left in King’s Landing is terribly tragic, but not if Robb and Lady Catelyn have anything to say about it. Their abduction of Jamie was a crucial move and stands to be a useful bargaining chip in the future, but things only stand to get worse for everyone now. And that’s not even including what’s happening abroad: Jon Snow marching off into the North to face the otherworldly horrors that have started showing themselves and Daenerys re-introducing dragons to the world of men.
Bringing the first season to a close, I thought these two episodes did a pretty good job of flipping everything on its head and leaving us with a real sense of wanting to know what happens next. The world of Game of Thrones is a place of death, treachery and abandon, no doubt, but we, the audience, naturally insist that things will right themselves eventually. Until they do, the show has no qualms about pulling rugs out from under us. The loss of Sean Bean’s Ned and Jason Momoa’s Drogo is significant (and unfortunate, as I’m sure lots of viewers tuned in just for their presence alone), but the way I see it, now is the time for far more magnetic characters to come to the forefront. Where the series started out with Robert, Ned and Viserys pushing the narrative forward, it’s now Tyrion, Robb and Daenerys who are poised to face off for the Iron Throne. Seeing their lesser beginnings gives us a fundamental understanding of who we’re dealing with going forward, while every remaining ancillary character struggles to find a new place in this suddenly-changed world. In just ten episodes, Game of Thrones has gone further and done more than I’d expected (those incredibly dense, early episodes seem to have paid off) and I can only expect things to roar ahead full steam when the second season begins in early 2012.
Zoe: I literally just received a call from a friend who had just finished watching the show. She, unlike me, was not spoiled for this turn of events and so was able to say “I don’t know, I guess I just thought he’d get out of it somehow.” Exactly. It seems that Game of Thrones exists to be a critique of our expectations of fantasies stories, at least in part. There will be no mighty rescue of Ned by Robb, and Dany finds out that the reality of war can’t be washed away with good deeds. Of course, her harsh lesson ends with dragons, so it’s not all terrible. Meanwhile too much is happening with basically every other character for me to review here, but suffice to say, it looks like shit is going down. Knowing that this is all based off The War of the Roses–a thirty year long war thatstill manages to not be the longest war in English history–we’re probably in for the long haul. I couldn’t be more excited, as I’m really enjoying the show, but fighting the temptation to read the books and skip ahead in the plot is strong. Hopefully the show won’t even give me a reason to.
The Killing: “Orpheus Descending”
Scott: More like RATINGS descending, amirite??? But seriously, folks, I think The Killing dug its grave with this truly abysmal finale. Any whodunit is essentially a series of red herrings before finding out that, yep, this one person is a murderer, and when it comes down to it, that’s pretty boring. Twin Peaks brilliantly subverted that formula by creating a town full of people so interesting that you really didn’t care about the central conceit of the show at all. Despite all the ways AMC tried to draw parallels to that other great, Pacific Northwestern masterpiece about a mysterious young lady who’s found dead in the pilot, The Killing is even worse than a rote CBS detective show, because at least those shows know what they are while The Killing is a pointless mess with an added layer of completely unwarranted pretension, perfectly exemplified by the maddening interviews showrunner Veena Sud gave to every TV website Monday morning. Sud thinks she’s making a towering epic about the nature of evil, when she’s really making a potboiler that we’ve been a bazillion times before, with a lot of characters that we hate, even more that we don’t care about, and one that’s pretty great who is completely ruined in the final moments of the finale. Hopefully in season 2 she realizes that she’s pissed off every viewer who had the patience to stick with this stupid show and sees what she’s really making: a show that’s going to get cancelled when everyone bails the second Rosie Larsen’s killer is revealed.
Ryan and Tatum: The O’Neals: “A Home Coming”
Scott: Ryan O’Neal has been in some good movies, but he’s never been a good actor, and according to everything I’ve ever read about him, he’s a horrible son of a bitch. Every single one of his kids have A) been estranged from him for decades at a time, B) struggled with crippling drug/alcohol addiction, C) been introduced to those drugs/alcoholic beverages by him before being legal adult, and D) been sent to prison, usually with some involvement by him. This new show on Oprah’s OWN channel is set up as an attempt for his most famous child, Tatum, to reconnect with him, but so far it’s just filmed proof of what’s been rumored for so long. This guy is simply an awful person: vain, hateful, violent, petty, and pathologically incapable of loving anyone but Farrah Fawcett. He’s almost a cartoon villain; every person in the show has a story about him chasing them with a baseball bat, or throwing furniture at them, or him kicking them out of a car in the middle of the freeway, or snorting lines with him at the age of twelve. He’s 70 but leers at his young assistant, who’s “my muse, but she also works for me”, and tries to pick up his grandchildren’s 20 year old friends. He’s the most sickening reality show villain since Donald “My People Can’t Believe What They’re Finding” Trump, and it’s heartbreaking to see his daughter begging for his love while he debates “whether I should let her back into my heart.” I might stick it out for a few more episodes, but so far this thing is sad, not funny.
The Glee Project: “Individuality” and “Theatricality”
Dennis: So, I abandoned Glee earlier in the season, but strangely that hasn’t stopped me from watching and enjoying this reality competition to select someone for a recurring role on the sub par Fox series. Sure, this is another “brand extension” to accompany the oodles of merchandise and the concert tours, and yes there are some flourishes of regular Glee here, namely the dependence on already overplayed pop music (there are few things more horrifying than watching the contestants go apeshit over getting to sing “Firework,” like it’s the greatest song of all time). But, there are also things that this Project has that its parent show no longer features, which include the ability to have characters who seem real (not always a guarantee on a reality show, either), and who also seem consistent from episode, and also the ability to have a cohesive plot each week. Oh, and the cast members on this show actually sing live sometimes, at least sparing us the overproduced-and-yet-still-bad-karaoke-sounding stuff we’ve come to get watching Glee or worse yet, (shudder) listening to one of the 80000 soundtracks associated with the show. I’m curious to see who wins this competition. Since Glee is all about misfits, and many of the archetypes here (the big girl, the diva, the flamboyant and proud gay kid) already exist on the mothership, my money’s on suave little guy Matheus to ultimately reign supreme..
Switched At Birth: “American Gothic” and “Portrait of my Father”
Zoe: Watching something on ABC Family, I was expecting treacly hugs-all-around programming. I wasn’t expecting to be so consistently annoyed at missed writing opportunities. It’s not that the show is bad–it’s fairly middling, all things considered–but that with minor changes, it could be so much better. Take, for example, D.W. Moffett’s character. He’s supposed to be a well-meaning dad, but a lot of the time he just comes off as such a jerk. Which is every character D.W. Moffett has ever played, but on this show we’re supposed to take a few redeeming moments as a sign of him being a good guy. Ditto Mrs. McFly. Meanwhile, Daphne’s mom is supposed to be seen as angry, despite that being both a horrible stereotype and just not true. Is she angry? Sure. But two people are trying to steal her daughter from her. I’d be a little teed off too. I honestly don’t know if I’m going to be able to keep watching this show, because right now it makes me yell for an hour.
Camelot: “The Battle of Bardon Pass”, “Reckoning”
Robert: After Igraine found her way back to Camelot, Morgan’s dirty deeds had already been done, and the fallout between Leontes and Guinevere (albeit a bit too soap opera-ish for my tastes) was felt immediately. He couldn’t reconcile her dalliance with Arthur and she couldn’t find her way back into his heart. When Merlin finds out, he lashes out at Arthur for foolishly risking his credibility as king. And yet, that’s only the beginning of Morgan’s plan. She also sends a company of men to take Bardon Pass, hoping to draw Arthur and his best men (including Kay, Gawain and a reluctant Leontes) out into the open while leaving the people of Camelot fearful and without a leader. After Arthur’s team takes some losses, he orders them back to Camelot and stays behind, both to prove his dedication to them and give them time to escape unseen.
As that all plays out, Merlin and Igraine are left to hold down the fort, but Morgan makes her move on Camelot and believing Arthur’s death is imminent, prepares to finally take the crown for herself. Her ability to work both sides—showing the people that she can be the compassionate, reliable leader they need and playing Arthur, Merlin and Igraine for fools that they may or may not be—serves her coup effort well, but while under attack at Bardon Pass, Arthur’s resourcefulness and sheer determination to stay alive becomes the last tiny glimmer of hope for Camelot’s future. When Bardon Pass is overrun and his men double back to save him, Leontes goes down and Arthur, knowing that Guinevere will be heartbroken, is overcome with guilt. When they return to Camelot, Morgan is quickly dismissed once Arthur provides evidence that she was the one who had been behind everything, but not before she deals a deadly hand to Igraine. Arthur commands a swift and brutal justice be dealt to Morgan, but Cybil steps up and assumes all responsibility, condemning herself to a hard and cold traitor’s death.
In contrast to Game of Thrones, Camelot is easily the more palatable medieval fantasy of 2011 because, if nothing else, its characters aren’t as viciously gung-ho about conspiring and backstabbing. Not to mention, having a lead character like Arthur who stands at the heart of the show as a virtuous model of what every other character aspires to gives viewers something to easily latch on to. Sure, he’s young, idealistic and reckless (and due to Jamie Campbell Bower’s sometimes meek appearance and demeanor, a bit ill-suited as king), but he fights for what’s right and when pushed, can push back like the best of them. Eva Green’s Morgan carries herself with a certain campy, deluded honor, and ultimately she just wants to claim her birthright of the throne even if her methods are wholly unsound. On its own merits, the first season of Camelot has been a noble attempt to re-imagine a time-honored legend while also challenging viewers with new wrinkles here and there. Speaking of which, considering Morgan’s conniving, totally-incestuous move in its final minutes, I’m curious to see where Camelot goes from here, should it be picked up for another season.
Love Bites: “Keep on Truckin” and “Sky High”
Dennis: It’s interesting, this show is all about getting TV mainstays as guest stars (these two episodes featured That 70s Show’s Laura Prepon, Community’s Ken Jeong, Cougar Town’s Spencer Locke, and the Old Spice guy himself Isaiah Mustafa), but I find myself wishing even more as these episodes go on that we’d spend more time with Becki Newton and only Becki Newton, especially as her character develops a flirtation with Jack & Bobby/Mad Men’s Matt Long (another go-to TV guy). Considering Love is likely to um, bite the dust, I’m hoping Newton soon gets the star-making TV role she so totally deserves.
Jamie Oliver’s Food Revolution: “We’re Going to Go Guerilla” and “Feed Them Healthy Food with 77 Cents”
Dennis: This season is only six episodes, and yet by episodes 4 and 5 even that’s starting to feel a little long. Don’t get me wrong, I still think this incredibly moving and powerful show got the shaft this season, shipped off to summer to air its remaining episodes mostly unnoticed, but I’m starting to wonder if Jamie had enough material this year. While season one of the series, allowed Jamie into a West Virginia school to really bring positive change to the community, this second season is forced to be about Jamie’s struggle to even get into a school, with school boards terrified of what the erstwhile Naked Chef will find lurking in their cafeteria kitchens. Watching Jamie unable to even get near LA’s school food is certainly disconcerting (what are they trying to hide?), but I find myself increasingly more interested in the episodes’ B-plots, as Jamie tries to help families and business owners, one by one, with their food choices. Here’s hoping if Jamie Oliver gets the chance to retool Revolution, it’s this more personal interaction he focuses on in the future.